Thank you Bruins for sending the BCS into another tizzy and exposing it for the crappy system that it is. Nonetheless, until we switch to the long overdue playoff system, the BCS is what we have right now, and it can at least do one thing right this season by putting Michigan into the title game. “But what about the Gators?” Urban Meyer asks. To that, I present to you the case for Michigan.
Urban Meyer says:
“We’ve played the toughest schedule.”
True, but Michigan has played the 3rd hardest schedule and Cincinnati has played the 2nd. Why shouldn’t Cincinnati be in title talks? I suppose it comes down to the record, and since Michigan and FLA both lost a game (with Michigan's one loss coming from the #1 team by a mere 3 points and FLA's loss coming from the #10 team by 10 points), I suppose then it comes down to...
“Huh? Style points?”
Urban Meyer claims it’s impossible to get style points with the schedule that they’ve played. Sure, it probably is difficult to score style points against Tennessee, LSU, and Auburn, but what about Vandy, South Carolina, and FSU? FLA won 5 games by 7 points or less, and 4 of those were against unranked opponents. Seriously, FSU? Wake Forest was able to shut out FSU with 30 huge “style points.” Granted FLA has beaten a few respectable teams, but the fact that they almost lost to so many crappy teams means that they are one thing: inconsistent. A team that inconsistent should not be allowed to play in the championship game, and I'd rather see Boise State get their chance before I see FLA.
“Non conference winners should not be allowed to play in the national championship.”
Touche Mr. Meyer. I think this is the only semi-legitimate argument. While this logically makes sense (how can you possibly be the best in the country if you aren’t even the best in your conference?), I think that Michigan and OSU should play again to possibly debunk the theory that OSU is the best in the Big Ten. Michigan lost by 3 points at OSU, from a late helmet to helmet call… does that really mean that OSU is the best team in the Big Ten? If OSU really is the absolute undisputed #1, then why are we even having a national championship game?
"The SEC is the toughest conference."
The reason why the SEC is tough is because they've got so many teams that are all about the same (good teams, but not amazing), making it hard for one team to significantly pull away. But that definitely doesn't mean that the winner of this evenly balanced conference is necessarily the best in the nation. It just means that they're the best of the above-averages. And even at this point, I'm still not entirely convinced that FLA is even really the best in the SEC.
“Michigan had their chance, let someone else get their’s.”
Just because Michigan had a chance and lost doesn’t mean that I think we should say, let my brother’s high school football team get a shot against OSU. The BCS title game should be between the top 2 teams in the nation (something that FLA definitely is NOT) and it shouldn’t matter if they have already played during the year.
I hate the people that are voting for Florida just because they are anti-rematch. These are the same people that had their noses halfway up USC's ass last week, before USC got pummeled by UCLA. And now these same people love FLA, saying that they deserve a title shot, when somehow they seemed to be quite unworthy last week. These people have no sense of who the real #2 is and are voting undeserving teams in just so that there won't be a Michigan/OSU rematch. I mean if they are voting for FLA because they truly believe that FLA, who had trouble with Georgia, Vandy, S. Car, and FSU, are really #2, then so be it. But if they are voting for FLA just because they are anti-rematch, then these people have no business voting in the polls.
As you can tell, I'd make a terrible sports analyst since I am utterly and completely biased towards Michigan. But I'm pretty sure that even if I wasn't a rabid Michigan fan, I'd still be reaching the same conclusions. Oh yeah... did I not totally call UCLA and LSU? And FLA really shouldn't have won. They were sucking it up until Reggie Fish's botched punt return literally handed them 7 free points on a silver platter.
Chatboard (0)